Best practices for catch-and-release shark angling: current scientific understanding and future research

In recent decades, the abundance of sharks in the world’s oceans has decreased due to overexploitation by commercial fisheries. Over this same period, sharks have been increasingly targeted for sport by recreational anglers. “Catch-and-release” (C&R) angling, where sharks are released alive after capture, has been proposed, and in some situations, mandated as a conservation measure in recreational fisheries. In C&R fisheries, anglers are encouraged to follow best practices, each with the goal of maximising post-release survivorship (PRS) of angled fish. Here for sharks, we review C&R global best practices and the science underpinning them. Despite shark C&R fishing being practiced globally, peer-reviewed research into post-release survivorship is limited to just twelve studies for eight species (Lamniformes, n = 3; Carcharhiniformes, n = 5). PRS in studies ranged from 56% to 100%. Identifying causes for decreased PRS (i.e. mortality) was challenging for studies due to low sample sizes. Of the factors investigated, candidate best practices included: (1) using non-stainless steel circle hooks, (2) not removing sharks from the water, (3) reviving sharks prior to release, and (4) minimising time spent freeing the shark by removing the hook or cutting the line. With the conservation status of many sharks declining, more research is needed to strengthen the scientific basis for these practices to ensure that PRS in C&R is maximised.